List your business, claim #1 on the Hyderabad board
Pink Power Run 3.0, 27 September 2026, People's Plaza Hyderabad, 5am onwards. Register now.
Back to Mumbai

Bombay HC Splits Rs 10.94 Crore Prabhadevi Land Compensation Between Owners and Tenant

Bombay HC Splits Rs 10.94 Crore Prabhadevi Land Compensation Between Owners and Tenant

The Bombay High Court on Tuesday ordered an equal split of Rs 10.94 crore in land acquisition compensation between the owners of a Prabhadevi plot and long-standing tenant Sadanand Garage. The 642.98-square-metre property was acquired by the State to construct a waiting hall and rest house for devotees visiting the Shree Siddhivinayak Ganapati Temple.

Justice Amit Borkar fixed the market value of the plot at Rs 1,70,200 per square metre, referenced to the valuation date of September 19, 2002. Under the ruling, both the plot owners and Sadanand Garage will receive Rs 5.47 crore each from the land compensation total. An additional Rs 3.85 lakh awarded for existing on-site structures and trees was granted entirely to the property owners.

The legal dispute arose after both parties sought majority shares of the payout. Sadanand Garage claimed to have occupied the entire property since 1971 and demanded a 75 per cent share, while the landowners argued they were entitled to the full amount. The court dismissed both claims, noting that the garage demonstrated long-term tenancy without proving exclusive rights across the whole plot, while the owners could not ignore the tenant's lawful presence.

Examining the evidence, Justice Borkar noted that rent receipts, municipal tax records, electricity bills, and business licences confirmed the garage’s sustained occupation and commercial activity. The judge observed that while the owners proved their ownership interest, their claim to the entire compensation failed because the land remained subject to the established tenancy rights of the garage.

On the question of valuation, the court rejected the State government’s reliance on ready reckoner rates, citing Supreme Court rulings that ready reckoner values lack statutory backing for setting market value under Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. Instead, the court evaluated two genuine comparable sales in the vicinity, which indicated rates of Rs 1,70,200 and Rs 1,76,500 per square metre, while factoring in road frontage, development potential, and proximity to the temple.

The court also dismissed third-party claims on the compensation fund, including a Rs 20 lakh claim by Century Developers, whose development agreement had been terminated and specific performance suit dismissed. Similarly, claims from prospective flat purchasers were rejected due to an absence of enforceable interest in the land, though the court noted their contractual remedies remain intact. The competent authority was directed to compute and disburse the funds within eight weeks.

Share

Related Stories